Showing posts with label great thinkers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label great thinkers. Show all posts

We might lose




It was winter 1998. The NBA conference finals had the five-time champion Chicago Bulls pitted against the underdog Indiana Pacers. Michael Jordan and his Bulls were in a bind, forced all the way to a game 7. 

In a tight must-win situation like this, what would you expect a coach to tell his team? 

“You’ll come through.” 

“If you play this game ten times, you might lose nine, but not this one.” 

Instead, the legendary zen Bulls coach, Phil Jackson, told his team: 

“We might lose.” 

-- 

This past week I went for an interview at Washington University in St. Louis, one of the best medical schools in the country. I thought I was a pretty good applicant, but I wasn’t really expecting to be given a shot at such a prestigious school. Just by the numbers, I would land in the lower 10-20% of their entering class. Numbers aren’t everything, but it means something. 

The first day was a casual day for the nine of us being interviewed that day to meet students and see the facilities. While eating lunch, we chatted about where we were coming from, etc. Everyone else was from Harvard or the NIH or Penn, top cut institutions. I guess I should have known that these are the kids that come to interview at a top 5 med school, but I was still caught off guard. 

I came from a small school in Ohio, and since getting out of college, I’ve gotten used to the casual attitude of Portland. I guess in those five years, I forgot about all the eliteness, and it definitely threw me off. I spent a few hours after that being intimidated as we took a tour of the facilities – shiny and expensive. 

The second day was the real test, a lineup of seven or eight faculty interviews, including a 20 minute panel interview with thirteen faculty members. I didn’t do my best, but I walked away feeling like I tried my best. I had good conversations, made some friends, and communicated at least to a couple faculty members what I was about. There’s not much more to life than feeling like you’ve given it your best. 

But walking away that day, the realization on my head was that I might not be going to medical school next fall. I always thought since I was a good candidate I would get in somewhere, but I realized the pool of candidates is overflowing with qualified candidates. 

If you’ve tried to find a job in the past couple years, I’m sure you know all about this. 

--

Phil Jackson showed some serious swagger to acknowledge that the Bulls, despite having an unmatched history, could still lose. Jackson didn't want a pity party, but he just wanted to lay down the simple straightforward reality. In sports, one team wins, and another team loses. And it is always important to know the reality. 

Nobody ever wants to talk about losing or making mistakes, but it doesn't have to be a negative part of the reality, and it should be ok to talk about it. 

Of course, the 1998 Chicago Bulls won the NBA championship. 

See you on the other side, 

from ken  

Feel free to comment! I would love to hear your thoughts.

Proof-of-principle



I work in a research lab at Oregon Health & Science University. There, I study the cellular mechanisms underlying iron homeostasis, but OHSU is best known as the home of Gleevec.

Brain Druker, an oncologist-researcher at OHSU, discovered Gleevec. It’s a drug that completely cures a type of leukemia (white blood cell cancer) with few side effects. This is a stark contrast to other cancers, that are attacked by surgery, radiation, and chemotherapy that kill healthy cells and have deadly side effects.


Cancer is scary. It can be activated by external factors like smoking, but it is a disease caused by your own body. Tumors are caused by your own cells that grow uncontrollably. Cancer differs from say, diseases of poverty, or diseases of gender, because it is caused by the cellular mechanisms that are common to every human being.


As a result, cancer does not bias itself, and it has a tendency to pick the most devastating targets. Katie’s friend from home was recently diagnosed with a malignant brain tumor. Said friend is only thirty, has a wife, two kids, and another on the way.


For years, scientists that study the cellular mechanisms responsible for cancer had been convinced that you could target cancer in ways other than blindly killing cells, by just targeting the mechanisms that cause cancer growth. Insert Gleevec, which targets a specific mechanism of leukemia cells, and only kills cancerous white blood cells.


Gleevec is a miracle of a cancer drug, and it will probably win Druker a Nobel Prize one day, but it’s greatest strength is as a proof-of-principle experiment.
I recently came across the idea of proof-of-principle, and I’ve been intrigued by it.


Here’s a sidenote to explain proof-of-principle:


Before Pixar started its series of computer animated movies like Toy Story and Finding Nemo, it first launched a mini-movie to test out the principle of animating human facial expressions. It was a success, and Pixar went ahead and produced larger projects like Toy Story. The mini-movie wasn’t the ultimate goal, but it was necessary to open the door for a whole genre/type of movies.


The type of leukemia that Gleevec cures is a relatively rare cancer, but it has single-handedly proven that it’s possible to hone in and eliminate cancerous cells without harming healthy cells. It is, simply, the proof to all scientists, doctors, and thirty year old brain tumor patients, that cancer can be cured.


As a scientist, I’m interested in Gleevec as a proof-of-principle experiment in cancer research.


But my real interest in science is bigger.


Before Gleevec, everyone was satisfied with the marginal gains of traditional chemotherapy or surgery. After Gleevec, the paradigm has completely shifted, and there is an entirely new option for cancer therapy. It’s still a little bit hazy in trying to get on that road, but Gleevec has proved to the doubters that the road exists and that cancer can be cured.


Cancer researchers everywhere are hot on the trail for the next Gleevec, and I see them as the scientists trying to get on the Gleevec road. But I also see other scientists who are looking for the roads that lead to the Gleevec road.


And I think that’s what I’m interested in.


Are there shortcuts?


Are all roads leading there uphill?


Can you wander around with no maps and end up there?


As a scientist, I want to know what leads people to insights like Gleevec. What environments, what K through PhD educational programs, what sorts of communities foster these scientists?

Is it dumb luck?

Is it once in an eon creative geniuses given a touch and vision that cannot be taught?


I’m a scientist, so I think everything can be figured out. So I guess I am one to believe that it can’t be dumb luck, or an unteachable magic touch. So I want to know. I want to know the system that creates these great scientists and then set them loose.


from ken


Feel free to comment! I would love to hear your thoughts.

Why teach




The ever-popular NYTimes columnist David Brooks had a hit column a while ago called, “It’s not about you.” To summarize: the traditional sequence for recent college grads is to find yourself, and then go out and do something. As a counterpoint, Brooks suggests that life is about going out and doing something, and finding yourself in the process.

It made me think about my own dreams. I was recently browsing through OHSU med school’s blog and I saw they had a series entitled “Why I teach.” They were interviews with OHSU professors well-known for their commitment to teaching. It reminded me of my goal to mentor/teach, partly because my dream is to empower people who are passionate about their own dreams, but mostly so I can tell people what I think about life.

I attended a small liberal arts college where the professors deliberately chose a teaching-focused career, and now I attend a growing church that invests a lot of energy into developing leaders. Between the two, I feel like I’ve been spoiled. I can remember three professors from Kenyon in particular, that brought three different positives to teaching that I would love to emulate.


One was Chris Gillen, a biology professor I had for several classes. Despite teaching at Kenyon for years, he maintained a contagious enthusiasm during his 8 AM lectures that made it much easier to learn something, and actually stay awake.


A second was Joan Slonczewski, my research mentor who always went the extra yard to give her students experiences to move them forward beyond Kenyon. You could tell she just wanted to help.


A third was John Hofferberth, a professor I had for six grueling semesters of chemistry. The best part of Dr. H. was that even though he loved chemistry, he knew the students in his classes were not there because of their shared love for chemistry, but rather to excel at standardized tests. I admired his effort to prepare lectures, grade exams, and in whatever way train the students to get out of the classes what they needed.


My favorite part of all these great professors was that they understood their crucial role in the education process.
They knew that whatever the students learned at Kenyon was not the ultimate goal of their education. But at the same time, they had developed a keen understanding for how to reach students, and help them get exactly what they needed out of Kenyon. Maybe for a pre-med student in Orgo, it was to excel on the MCATs. Maybe for a pre-scientist, it was getting hands on research experience as an undergraduate. Maybe for a confused 18 year old, it was simply to be enthuiastic about life.

Anyways, seeing these great professors has really inspired me to love mentoring. Working on all the med school applications, the most common question is: Where do you see your career leading you?

And of course I have no idea, but I know I love academic medical centers. I have spent some time working at the behemoth of Harvard med school, as well as the smaller but still huge OHSU. Walking around these centers, I love seeing the nursing students, the physicians-in-training, the young scientists. Though these people are adults, as professionals, these people are almost infants, and I love the parent-like training role of leaders at these academic medical centers.


I think that parent-like role is fundamental to the balance of life.
Start out being trained and taken care of, and then as you learn more, teach others.

from ken

Are you thinking about something? Write about it and post it here! Email me! ken.e.noguchi@gmail.com

Pantheon Kenyon Commencement Speeches



I’m going to make a bold prediction. The last time you asked someone how they were doing, they told you one of these three things:


A) I’ve been busy.

B) I’m tired.
C) Both.


Thanks to the industrial revolution and the advent of iPhones, the modern world is dominated by multi-tasking and efficiency, which is great for mass producing TV’s and hot dogs, but it makes for a bunch of tired people. I figured the solution, of course, must be rest. So I posted a couple months back on wanting to get better at taking rest… and as you might expect, I’m still terrible at it.


The last few weeks, I’ve been super tired. The days in the lab have been longer, and nothing’s been working, so it leaves me drained and demoralized. The med school applications are piling up in my gmail inbox as I procrastinate further by writing this post instead. I also recently moved, so the packing and unpacking has been stressing me out. I know, I know, cry me a river, but really between all of it, I’ve been feeling like I have no time to myself.


When I’m tired like this, I just want to be lazy. I want to completely shut off and do nothing. But I think shutting off like that is a little bit like dying.

That’s what Jonathan Franzen and David Foster Wallace argued. These are two men who became powerhouse novelists through their attempt to make sense of the word by writing. They philosophized about life on a pantheon level. And on top of that, they both gave commencement speeches at my alma matter, Kenyon College.

Franzen gave a commencement speech called, “Liking is for cowards. Go for what hurts.” He argues that modern technology makes people passive. People would rather sit on facebook and follow their digital friends or watch porn than go out and form messy but real relationships. It's a hell of a lot easier to have virtual friends that never ask anything of you, ruin your plans, or make you look stupid.

Wallace spoke five years ago on a similar topic, explained via parable:

Two young fish are chatting along and swimming through the water, when an older fish swims past them, and asks them, “Howdy boys, how’s the water?” and continues on. Later, one of the two young fish asks the other, “What’s water?”

He was asking everybody in that Kenyon audience to turn their heads away from their iPads and pay attention to the world. He knew that the more you pay attention to the world, the more apparent it is that the world isn’t about serving your own personal needs.

I had a friend ask what he thought was the greatest problem facing the world. I think the world got confused about the meaning of the world. Everyone is convinced that the world revolves around them, but actually, when we die, the world goes on.

Franzen and Wallace both came to a similar conclusion: good things take work. Technology might have deceived us into thinking that we don't have to put work into relationships, but how satisfying is it to watch a funny TV show or a friend's blog post? I know I've never sat on my porch at the end of the day and thought to myself, "Damn, I watched some hilarious TV shows today."


I don’t mean we aren’t “working” enough, as in we aren’t filling out our days with impressive to do lists. I mean that society as a whole is not paying enough attention to the water around us. We’ve stopped appreciating our best friends, making small talk with our Trader Joe’s cashier, or looking out for that beautifully optimistic dandelion sprouting out between sidewalks.

It takes a hell of a lot of work to always pay attention, sometimes it hurts. I know when I when I’m having a bad day, I’d rather ignore everybody else and sulk away in my rotten mood.


But why turn inward?

Is it really easier to get through life if you turn off the surrounding sounds?

When did life become about comfort?


from ken


Are you thinking about something? Write about it and post it here! Email me! ken.e.noguchi@gmail.com